Book Review: Distant Journeys By David Katzenstein

blog

Book Review: Distant Journeys By David Katzenstein

September 18th, 2024 by Michael Ernest Sweet

David Katzenstein’s Distant Journeys is a book that offers both promise and disappointment. While it showcases a number of outstanding photographs, it is ultimately hampered by issues of editing and presentation.

The collection is unified by its monochrome palette, which serves as a consistent thread throughout the work. Katzenstein presents this book as an overview of his life’s work, with the publisher marketing it as a “journey through journeys.” However, the concept of distilling a lifetime of photography into a single volume raises questions about whether such an ambitious scope can truly do justice to the breadth and depth of an entire career. This overarching challenge affects the ability to appreciate the individual photographs in their own right.

Katzenstein’s talent as a photographer is evident. Many of his images are compelling, and some are genuinely exceptional. The book evokes comparisons to renowned photographers like Daido Moriyama, Larry Fink, Bruce Gilden, Josef Koudelka, and Lee Friedlander. It is clear that Katzenstein has not only practiced photography but has also studied it deeply. His skill in composition and his mastery of monochrome photography are notable; his work effectively makes one forget the world’s inherent color—a rare and impressive achievement.

However, the earlier portions of the book stand out more vividly than the later works. Katzenstein’s pre-2000 images, such as the 1996 photograph of two men with binoculars in New York City and the striking 1985 and 1996 images of horses and pyramids in Giza, demonstrate a bold and innovative storytelling prowess. These earlier works exhibit a distinctive signature that seems less pronounced in his post-2000 photography, which, despite its merits, feels less cohesive and engaging.

Additionally, the decision to include excerpts from novelist Paul Bowles, though eloquent, does not necessarily enhance the photographic experience. Katzenstein’s photographs are strong enough to stand on their own without the added literary layer, which merely dilutes the visual impact.

In summary, Distant Journeys is a collection of impressive photographs that struggles with the ambition of its scope and presentation. David Katzenstein’s evident skill as a photographer is clear, but the current format may not fully honor the complexity and evolution of his work. A more focused presentation, possibly highlighting his earlier works separately, might have allowed his artistry to be more fully appreciated.

Distant Journeys
By David Katzenstein
Hirmer Publishers, Hardcover
US$ 60 / EU 59 / UK £50
184 pages
120 duotone photographs

About Michael Ernest Sweet

Michael Ernest Sweet is a Canadian photographer, writer, and art critic. He is the author of The Human Fragment and Michael Sweet's Coney Island. Michael has written about photography for over a decade for publications such as the HuffPost, FStoppers, StreetPhotography.com, as well as print-based magazines like Photo Life and Digital Camera. He is the recipient of a Queen's Medal for significant contributions to the arts and education in Canada.

View all posts by Michael Ernest Sweet →

Location: Online Type: Black and White, Book Review

blog